Ideas & historyInterpretation
Hayek vs Scott: two sceptics of the plan, from different sides
Hayek trusted prices and general rules; James C. Scott feared the market's standardising too. What the two sceptics share, where they split, and what Spain can use.
In short
F. A. Hayek and James C. Scott both argue that central planners cannot see the knowledge a society runs on. Hayek's answer is prices and general rules, which let people on the spot act on what only they know. Scott, a man of the left, adds that large-scale capitalism also standardises and wipes out practical know-how (mētis), and he asks what happens when power turns market choice into an offer nobody can refuse. A radical-centre reading keeps general rules at the top, local discretion at the bottom, and treats the people who do the work as a source of knowledge, as Spain's farm-notebook reversal of 2025 shows.
Key points
- Hayek's 1945 essay 'The Use of Knowledge in Society' (American Economic Review) argues that knowledge of particular circumstances of time and place is scattered, and prices pass on what matters about it.
- In the introduction to Seeing Like a State (1998) Scott says his case against the planning state is no case for unfettered markets as urged by Hayek or Milton Friedman, because large-scale capitalism also homogenises.
- Robert Reamer (Critical Review, 2024) argues that Hayek's local knowledge is mostly knowledge of facts, while Scott's mētis is know-how, which market competition can erase.
- In 2010 Scott granted that markets achieve a tacit coordination no command could, and called the Hayekian case for small traders in competitive markets a strong one.
- Spain's Real Decreto 34/2025 made the digital farm notebook voluntary, kept paper as an option and set size thresholds for the next CAP period; EU rules from May 2024 exempt farms of up to 10 hectares from conditionality controls and penalties.
Friedrich A. Hayek and James C. Scott make an odd couple. Hayek was the Austrian economist who wrote The Constitution of Liberty (1960) and became a patron saint of market liberals. Scott was a Yale political scientist who spent his life with peasants, ran the university's Program in Agrarian Studies and wrote a book called Two Cheers for Anarchism. Both of them distrusted the plan. On this site we have explained Hayek's book and Scott's Seeing Like a State on their own, and set each against Mariana Mazzucato (Hayek, Scott). This week ends by putting the two sceptics in a room together, because the place where they part company is where radical centrism has the most to learn.
Hayek's case starts in his 1945 essay "The Use of Knowledge in Society", printed in the American Economic Review. The knowledge an economy runs on, he wrote, never exists in one head. A great deal of it is knowledge of the particular circumstances of time and place, the kind held by the shipper who earns his living filling half-empty tramp steamers or the estate agent who lives off temporary opportunities. No ministry can collect it. Prices pass on the part that matters: when tin gets scarcer, users only need to see its price rise, and they economise without knowing why. Hayek called the price system a kind of telecommunications. In The Constitution of Liberty he turned this into politics: government should act through general, known rules, and leave people free to use what they alone know.
Scott opens Seeing Like a State (Yale University Press, 1998) with the Prussian forest replanted as rows of spruce so the treasury could count it, a forest that thrived for one generation and then sickened. States, he argues, make society legible by simplifying it, and the disasters come when planners sweep aside mētis, the practical know-how of the farmer, the sailor or the worker who knows how a machine really behaves.
Where Scott parts from Hayek
Scott saw the family resemblance and dealt with it in the book's introduction. As the political economist Robert Reamer quotes him in a 2024 paper in Critical Review, Scott wrote that his charge sheet against the planning state is no case for the unfettered markets urged by Hayek or Milton Friedman. On the same page he calls large-scale capitalism an agency of homogenisation, uniformity and grids just as much as the state is, with one difference: "for capitalists, simplification must pay." He repeated the point in 2010, in an essay for the Cato Institute's online journal Cato Unbound: the profit motive brings its own tunnel vision.
Reamer's reading makes the split precise. Hayek's local knowledge is mostly knowledge of facts: a spare stock, an idle machine, a short-lived opportunity. Scott's mētis is knowledge of how to do something in a particular place, how to farm this soil or navigate this river. Prices are wonderful at carrying the first kind. They are also, Reamer argues, a form of legibility, because they work by condensing information and dropping the rest. The second kind can be wiped out by competition from standardised methods, with effects that look a lot like the state's forced simplifications. Reamer also points to a passage where Hayek himself admits something close to this, describing progress as an involuntary affair for most people, forcing changes on them they do not want.
Scott was generous about the other side. In his replies to the Cato exchange he granted that markets are a form of tacit coordination that could never be reached by command, and he called the Hayekian case for small traders in competitive markets a strong one. His worry was power. Firms, he wrote, try through lobbying and legal manoeuvring to turn small, uncertain profits into guaranteed rents, and wealth lets them turn a market of price-takers into an oligopoly of price-givers. He asked Hayek scholars what Hayek had to say when disparities of power make free choice feel like an offer nobody can refuse. And he added that legibility is a capacity, neither good nor bad in itself, whose worth depends on what it is used for.
A Spanish field notebook
Spanish agriculture has just tested this. Real Decreto 1054/2022 set up SIEX, a national information system on farms, a regional register, and the Cuaderno Digital de Explotación Agrícola (CUE), an electronic notebook in which farmers record what they do on their land. The original plan made the CUE compulsory for every farm, phased in by type. Small farms were exempted later. Then Real Decreto 34/2025, of 21 January, made it voluntary unless a sectoral rule requires electronic records, and let farmers keep the notebook on paper or digitally, as they choose. Its preamble says the aim is to reach the same control while preserving farmers' ability to decide how to hand over the information. The digital notebook becomes compulsory in the next CAP period only for farms over 30 hectares, with more than 5 hectares of irrigation, or with greenhouses over 0.1 hectares.
Brussels moved the same way. The CAP simplification regulation that entered into force on 25 May 2024 exempts farmers with up to 10 hectares from conditionality controls and the penalties attached to them, a group the Commission puts at 65% of CAP beneficiaries. It also dropped the compulsory minimum share of fallow land and gave member states room to exempt certain crops, soils and farming systems.
Read with Hayek, that is a general rule at the top with fewer case-by-case inspections. Read with Scott, it is a state that wanted to see every field and found that legibility has a cost for the people being seen. Scott would add the other half of his warning: the small grower also lives under the standards of large buyers and long supply chains, which simplify the field as surely as any inspector.
Our position takes from both and adds a method. From the left, and from Scott, we take the duty to protect mētis and the communities that hold it, from ministries and also from market power, with competition policy that stops large buyers becoming price-givers and rules that leave room for small producers. From the liberal market tradition, and from Hayek, we take prices and general, predictable rules as the best way to let dispersed knowledge work. The part that belongs to neither is how the rules get made. Start small and reversible: pilot a data obligation like the CUE in a few comarcas, measure what it costs and what it teaches, and scale it only then, with thresholds reviewed against the results. Write the general rule at the top and leave local discretion at the bottom, the way Valencia's Water Tribunal has let irrigators run their own canals for centuries. And treat the people who do the work, the farmer, the inspector, the cooperative's technician, as a source of knowledge with a formal channel into the rule, the job we gave our proposed productivity commission.
Democracia 21, in Miriam González's launch speech of 10 October 2026, called for a systematic, urgent review of outdated rules, duplication and needless procedures (our overview analyses it). Hayek and Scott together give that review its test. A good rule lets people use what they know, and it was written after asking the people who know.
Questions and answers
What is the difference between Hayek and James C. Scott?
Both distrust central planning because planners cannot see dispersed knowledge. Hayek concludes that prices and general rules should coordinate society. Scott agrees that markets coordinate in ways commands cannot, and adds that large firms, standard commodities and concentrated power also simplify the world and destroy practical know-how.
Did James C. Scott write about Hayek?
Yes. In the introduction to Seeing Like a State he says his critique of the planning state is no brief for the unfettered markets urged by Hayek or Milton Friedman. In a 2010 Cato Unbound exchange he called the Hayekian case for small traders in competitive markets strong, and asked Hayek scholars how it deals with large disparities of power.
What is mētis?
Mētis is Scott's word, taken from ancient Greek, for practical, local know-how: the knowledge of how to farm this field or sail this river, often so implicit that the person who has it cannot fully explain it.
What does radical centrism take from Hayek and Scott?
General, predictable rules at the top, room for local judgement at the bottom, protection for practical knowledge against standardising from states and large firms alike, and policy built as small reversible steps tested with the people who do the work.
Sources
- Markets and Metis: Reading Hayek with Scott. Critical Review (Robert Reamer), via King's College London (2024)
- The Trouble with the View from Above. Cato Unbound (James C. Scott) (2010)
- Some Replies on Markets, Languages, and Law. Cato Unbound (James C. Scott) (2010)
- The Use of Knowledge in Society. Library of Economics and Liberty (American Economic Review, 1945) (1945)
- Real Decreto 34/2025, de 21 de enero (Cuaderno digital de explotación agrícola). BOE (2025)
- Targeted review of the CAP: simplification for farmers (2024/0073(COD)), document summary. European Parliament Legislative Observatory (2024)