Ideas & historyInterpretation

Scott vs Mazzucato: missions without hubris, from Spain's PERTEs to Germany's SPRIND

Can a state chase Mazzucato's moonshots without becoming the high-modernist planner James C. Scott warned about? Two European cases show how.

Comic illustration: at El Faro, Theo studies a rocket with a gold nose cone through a magnifier, Lucía waves a plant and Nora lifts a map, while the rocket's base spreads into a tangle of small roots and paths through the data fog and Punto in a graduation cap floats in the sky.

In short

Yes, if the mission fixes the goal and leaves the method to the people on the ground. James C. Scott's Seeing Like a State (1998) blames disaster on schemes imposed by authoritarian power on a civil society too weak to resist; Mariana Mazzucato's Mission Economy (2021) asks the state to set bold goals and invest in them. Spain's electric-vehicle PERTE, audited by the Court of Audit in 2026, shows the failure mode, and Germany's SPRIND, which funds competing teams in stages and drops the weaker ones, shows a working one. The radical-centre rule: a public goal, many small reversible bets, and local say over method.

Key points

  • Scott's warning in Seeing Like a State targets a specific mix: administrative ordering, high-modernist confidence, authoritarian power and a civil society too weak to push back.
  • Mazzucato herself asks missions to use bottom-up experimentation and to know when to turn the tap off, which brings her closer to Scott than her critics admit.
  • Spain's Court of Audit found that the electric-vehicle PERTE brought industry in late, had governance bodies that rarely met, no structured monitoring and a first call too complex for many firms.
  • Germany's SPRIND funds competing teams in stages: its 2024 digital-wallet competition funded six teams, then up to four, then up to two.
  • The EU missions' 2026 mid-term assessment praises co-creation in living labs and real places, and reports no route that was stopped or redirected.

Mariana Mazzucato wants the state to aim high. In Mission Economy (2021) she asks governments to pick goals worth a Moon landing, such as clean cities or beating cancer, and to build budgets, research and business partnerships around them. James C. Scott spent Seeing Like a State (Yale University Press, 1998) on what happens when states aim high and get it badly wrong: the spruce rows of Prussian forestry, Brasília, Soviet collective farms, Tanzania's compulsory villages. We have explained Scott's book and Mazzucato's on their own, and set Mazzucato against Hayek in an earlier confrontation. This piece takes the harder question for anyone who likes missions, radical centrists included, of whether a state can run one without turning into the high-modernist planner Scott warned about. Europe already has evidence that it can, along with evidence of how it goes wrong.

What Scott actually feared

Scott's target is precise. Yale's description of the book names four conditions that together produce disaster: an administrative ordering of nature and society, a high-modernist ideology confident that science can improve every part of human life, a willingness to use authoritarian power to push large schemes through, and a civil society too weak to resist. The same description says local, practical knowledge matters as much as formal, technical knowledge for any social order to work. Scott calls that practical knowledge metis: the farmer's feel for her soil, the clerk's sense of which form people never manage to fill in.

Near the end of the book Scott offers rules for planning when you cannot know enough. Mandy Brown's reading notes reproduce them from page 345. Take a small step, stand back, observe, then plan the next small move. Prefer interventions that can easily be undone. Choose plans that leave the most room for the unforeseen. And assume that the people who join the project later will have the experience to improve on the design.

Put that list next to Mazzucato and the distance shrinks. In a 2019 interview with the Commission's Horizon magazine she said missions must use bottom-up experimentation to reach a specific goal and could fail by being too top-down. She said knowing when to turn the tap off matters, suggested reviewing a mission after about three years and reframing it if it is not working, and wanted citizens involved in monitoring missions as well as framing them.

So the real disagreement is narrow. Mazzucato trusts a capable state to choose the destination and to keep the search honest. Scott doubts that a state sees enough of the ground to do the second part, and he fears the moment a mission hardens into a single blueprint drawn in a ministry. A mission passes Scott's test when it keeps his four conditions from ever meeting.

Two European cases

Spain's first PERTE shows the failure mode. The strategic project for the electric and connected vehicle, the PERTE VEC, was the first of the recovery plan's PERTEs. On 23 June 2026 the president of the Court of Audit presented its operational audit, covering 2021 to 2023, to the joint committee of the Congress and Senate. The design did not define the private sector's participation in advance; firms came in at later stages. The governance bodies met rarely, which made coordination hard. Indicators existed, but there was no structured monitoring system and no timetable for meeting them. The first call for aid was highly complex, with numerous requirements, and that held participation down. Later calls improved, and still a significant share of the money was waiting to be assigned. The Court recommended a procedure for designing future PERTEs that brings industry in from the start, and asked the industry ministry for effective governance and a framework for tracking objectives.

That is Scott's legibility problem in a modern form. A ministry drew a scheme that suited its own forms, and the firms and suppliers who knew the sector arrived late. Nobody could see whether a route was working, so nobody could stop it or change it.

Germany's SPRIND, the federal agency for breakthrough innovation founded in 2019 with its seat in Leipzig, runs the other way round. Its challenges go in stages, the work is evaluated at the end of each one, and only the best teams stay in and receive more money. Take the EUDI wallet competition, a 13-month contest run for the federal interior ministry in 2024 to prototype wallets for Europe's digital identity. SPRIND funded six teams in the first stage with up to €300,000 each, up to four in the second and up to two in the third. The goal stayed fixed, a wallet in which citizens can prove who they are and carry official documents. The routes competed, and the money moved to the routes that worked. SPRIND belongs wholly to the federal state and says part of its job is keeping the value created by the firms it backs in Germany and Europe.

The EU missions sit somewhere in between. The Commission's mid-term assessment of September 2026 describes living labs, lighthouses and pilots that develop and adapt solutions in real places, and co-creation in which the public and stakeholders test and refine them. The climate adaptation mission alone supports 185 regions and local authorities demonstrating nearly 1,000 solutions in real conditions. That is a great deal of metis at work. The same report says Horizon Europe's project rules are not entirely suited to the missions, and it names no route that was stopped or redirected. Mazzucato's tap is installed. Nobody reports turning it.

Where we land

The left brings direction and investment. A state can choose a goal that markets will not choose, put public money at risk on it, and expect the public to share in the reward, through stakes like the ones SPRIND's owners hold or through repayable aid. The liberal market tradition brings the discipline of discovery: many firms and teams try many routes, they compete, and the money stops when a route fails, which is how markets learn and how SPRIND runs its challenges. Scott adds what both usually leave out of the design. The people who will live with the result, the owner of a parts workshop in Navarre, a city housing officer, a GP running a screening programme, help write the method and keep adapting it. They get a veto over how a mission is done in their place and none over whether the goal is pursued. Bets stay small and reversible until the evidence says to scale them.

For Spain, the next PERTE would put firms, unions and regions at the table before the first call is written, set one target with a date, fund many small projects in stages with a published review at each stage, and print the list of what was stopped as proudly as the list of what won. Brussels still owes us that second list. Jennifer Pahlka would recognise every step, and the Next Generation funds are where Spain can start.

Questions and answers

What is the difference between Mazzucato and James C. Scott?

Mariana Mazzucato's Mission Economy (2021) argues that the state should choose bold goals, such as climate-neutral cities, and organise public investment and business partnerships around them. James C. Scott's Seeing Like a State (1998) studies how ambitious state schemes failed when they ignored local, practical knowledge and were imposed on people who could not resist. Mazzucato emphasises direction; Scott emphasises humility about what the centre can see.

What is high modernism?

In Scott's account, high modernism is a strong confidence that science and technical expertise can redesign every part of life. It becomes dangerous when it meets an administrative ordering of society, a state willing to use authoritarian power and a civil society too weak to resist, as in Soviet collectivisation or Tanzania's compulsory villages.

Can mission-oriented policy avoid Scott's criticism?

It can, when the goal is public and fixed while the method stays open: many teams compete in stages, places and front-line staff adapt the approach, reviews are published and failing routes lose their funding. Germany's SPRIND challenges work this way; Spain's first PERTE, for the electric vehicle, did not, according to the Court of Audit.

What did the Court of Audit say about the PERTE VEC?

Presenting its audit of 2021 to 2023 to Parliament on 23 June 2026, the Court's president said private participation was not defined in advance, the governance bodies met rarely, there was no structured monitoring system or timetable, the first call was highly complex, and a significant share of the money was still unassigned.

Sources

  1. Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed. Yale University Press (1998)
  2. Take small steps (reading notes on Seeing Like a State). A Working Library (Mandy Brown) (2024)
  3. Missions will require a revolution in European governments: Prof. Mariana Mazzucato. Horizon Magazine, European Commission (2019)
  4. Report from the Commission on the mid-term assessment of the EU Missions' progress, achievements and impact, COM(2026) 467 final. European Commission / Council of the European Union (2026)
  5. Diario de Sesiones de las Cortes Generales, Comisión Mixta para las Relaciones con el Tribunal de Cuentas, núm. 172. Cortes Generales (2026)
  6. 6 Teams qualifizieren sich für SPRIND Funke EUDI Wallet Prototypes. SPRIND, Bundesagentur für Sprunginnovationen (2024)

Get the week's articles by email