EuropeInterpretation

Next Generation funds and productivity: what Spain got from its Recovery Plan

Spain will end up with about €101 billion of EU recovery money. Growth got a lift, productivity barely moved. What worked, what didn't, and the lesson for 2028.

Comic illustration: in El Mercado, Carmen carries a coin, Theo points with a magnifying glass and Elena holds a notebook beside a huge funnel full of coins whose narrow spout drips just two coins onto a small gold cogwheel, next to a project sheet with a teal mark, a wall of permits behind them and Punto in a headset floating in the sky.

In short

Spain's Recovery Plan had about €160 billion available, used about €103 billion, and with its final payment request of 30 September 2026 the funds allocated reach €101.3 billion. The money added an estimated 1.4 to 2.1 points to GDP over 2021–2025 and some reforms stuck, such as the 2021 labour reform and the Kit Digital vouchers, but aggregate productivity barely moved and large firms took almost half the commitments. Read through Flyvbjerg and Pahlka, the lesson for the next EU budget and for the Spanish state is to run fewer and simpler programmes, test each one against a reference class before launch, and publish spending and results project by project.

Key points

  • Spain's final payment request, filed on 30 September 2026, asks for €25,861 million against 148 milestones and targets; with it, the funds allocated under the plan reach €101.3 billion.
  • Funcas and Afi estimate the funds explain 10–14% of Spain's GDP growth in 2021–2025, while business investment was still 3.3 points below its pre-pandemic level at the end of 2025.
  • Firms with more than 250 employees, 0.4% of all firms, took about 45.7% of commitments; microenterprises, 89.3% of firms, received about 10%.
  • The Banco de España finds Kit Digital raised the total factor productivity of beneficiary firms by about 1.2% a year after the grant; the PERTE Chip had resolved about 20% of its €12,250 million by April 2026.
  • The European Court of Auditors warns that the 2028–2034 partnership plans copy the recovery fund's model, which tracks progress more than results and does not require spending to be reported per operation.

On 30 September 2026, the last day allowed, Spain filed the seventh and final payment request of its Recovery, Transformation and Resilience Plan: €25,861 million against 148 milestones and targets, about 30% of everything the plan had promised. The deadline for meeting milestones had passed on 31 August, and the Commission has until 31 December to pay. Europa Press reported that, with this request, the funds allocated under the plan reach €101.3 billion. By 11 August, after the sixth payment, Spain had already received €78 billion.

The starting figure was bigger. Funcas and Afi, in a study presented on 23 April 2026, put the total available at about €160 billion in grants and loans. Spain asked for only a quarter of the loans on offer, so the effective envelope was around €103 billion. CaixaBank Research gives the split as of April: €79.8 billion of grants, and €22.8 billion of the €83.2 billion of loans.

What arrived, and what it did

Receiving money from Brussels and spending it in the economy are different stages, and every tracker measures a different one. At the end of 2025, Funcas and Afi counted €71,366 million received and €57,395 million committed, with spending in national-accounts terms at 55% of the total, close to €39 billion. Only about 60% of calls had been resolved.

The effect on growth is real. Funcas and Afi estimate that the funds explain between 10% and 14% of Spain's GDP growth over 2021–2025, between 1.4 and 2.1 points of GDP. And yet business investment was still 3.3 points below its pre-pandemic level in real terms at the end of 2025, and the authors describe productivity as showing limited dynamism. Xavier Vives, writing in Ara, notes that output per worker was flat between 2019 and 2025, and that a Banco de España survey found the green investment, close to 40% of the plan, was barely additional.

Some things clearly worked. The Banco de España's annual report, published on 18 June 2026, finds that Kit Digital, the standard voucher for small firms and the self-employed to buy basic digital tools, raised the total factor productivity of beneficiaries by about 1.2% a year after the grant. The same report links the 2021 labour reform to productivity: firms that had relied most on temporary contracts saw productivity grow on average about 0.9 points faster than moderate users over 2022–2024, compared with before the reform. Vives cites the Bank's finding that formal temporary employment fell from 25% in 2021 to 15% in 2025, though effective temporality fell much less. The pension reform, completed in March 2023 as a condition of the fourth payment, drew a 2024 Commission staff report finding that it raises long-run spending. Crea y Crece's mandatory electronic invoicing between firms, its main tool against late payment, finally got its implementing order on 5 October 2026 and applies from October 2027 for firms above €8 million and October 2028 for everyone else.

Then there is who got the money. Funcas and Afi find that firms with more than 250 employees, 0.4% of Spanish companies, absorbed about 45.7% of the commitments. Microenterprises, 89.3% of firms, received about 10%. Central government managed around 60% of the funds, the regions 25% and local councils 15%.

The PERTEs through Flyvbjerg's eyes

The strategic projects, the PERTEs, are where the plan's ambition showed most. El Independiente reported in April 2026 that their combined budget grew from €14,205 million to over €41,100 million. The PERTE Chip grew about 45-fold, from €275 million to €12,250 million, with €9,350 million, about 76%, for building fabrication plants. By September 2025 €880 million had been executed, according to Funcas and Afi, and by April 2026 about €2,513 million had been resolved, roughly 20%. The fabrication axis reached about 10%; the research, design and ICT axes were at 60–70%.

Bent Flyvbjerg, whose How Big Things Get Done we explained yesterday, would recognise the pattern. His rule is plan slow, act fast, and he forecasts any project from the real record of similar ones. The recovery fund ran in the opposite direction: plans written in months under pandemic pressure, then years of slow execution. A reference-class check on advanced chip plants would have shown at once that a single fab costs tens of billions, as the paper notes with Intel's $32 billion project in Arizona, and the chip industry's own association told the paper that the original model did not fit Spain's industrial base. The smaller research and design lines, which looked like things Spain had done before, moved far faster.

Jennifer Pahlka's Recoding America adds the delivery side. Kit Digital worked because it was a simple, standard product a small firm could claim without a lawyer. The big competitive calls rewarded applicants with a department to fill in the forms, and the figures on who got the money show who managed it.

The €10 billion, and the next budget

In her launch speech of 10 October 2026, Democracia 21's Miriam González spoke of €10 billion of European funds unexecuted. That is the party's claim, and it sits inside the independent range: Funcas and Afi put the gap between money received and committed close to €14 billion at the end of 2025, and CaixaBank put grants still to award at €15 billion by ELISA's count or over €20 billion by AIReF's. We traced where the leftover loans went, largely into the ICO's España Crece fund.

The bigger stake is the 2028–2034 budget. The Commission proposed in July 2025 a budget of about €2 trillion, with around €865 billion in a single European Fund run through one national and regional partnership plan per country, paid against milestones and targets on the recovery fund's model. The European Court of Auditors, in an opinion adopted on 12 February 2026, warns that this model focuses on implementation progress more than results, that its RRF audit found weak cost estimates, and that member states would not have to report public spending per operation.

A radical-centre position combines the best of each tradition. The left is right that Europe should borrow together to invest, and that cohesion money belongs in the regions and in small firms, so Spain's plan should reserve a real share for standard, Kit Digital-style instruments that a microenterprise can actually use. The liberal tradition is right that money should follow results, and the evidence so far shows a reform like the 2021 labour reform paying off more clearly than the biggest calls. What binds them is delivery capacity. Spain's partnership plan should carry fewer, simpler programmes, every large one tested against a published reference class before launch, and every project's cost, payments and results posted in open data as they happen, which the Commission could make a condition of payment. In Madrid, that means a delivery unit with the authority to stop a programme that fails its own test, and a regional say in the plans that comes with the same duty to publish.

Questions and answers

How much Next Generation EU money did Spain receive?

Spain had received €78 billion by 11 August 2026, after the sixth payment. On 30 September 2026 it filed its last request, for €25,861 million, and the Commission has until 31 December 2026 to pay. With that request the funds allocated under the plan reach €101.3 billion, out of about €160 billion originally available, because Spain took up only part of the loans.

Did the Next Generation funds raise Spain's productivity?

Only a little so far. Funcas and Afi credit the funds with 1.4 to 2.1 points of GDP over 2021–2025, but say productivity shows limited dynamism and the transformative effect has not yet fully arrived. The Banco de España finds clear gains in specific programmes, such as Kit Digital for small firms.

What happened to the PERTEs?

The strategic projects grew from about €14.2 billion to over €41.1 billion. The largest, the PERTE Chip, grew from €275 million to €12,250 million, three quarters of it for chip fabrication plants; by April 2026 about 20% had been resolved and the plant axis had reached about 10%.

Is it true that €10 billion of European funds are unexecuted?

It is Democracia 21's claim. The figure is in the range of the independent estimates: at the end of 2025 Funcas and Afi put the gap between money received and money committed close to €14 billion, and CaixaBank Research put grants still to be awarded at €15–20 billion depending on the source. Much of the leftover loan money has since gone into the ICO's España Crece fund.

Sources

  1. España pide 'in extremis' la séptima y última solicitud de pago de 25.861 millones del Plan de Recuperación. Europa Press / Diario Estrategia (2026)
  2. NGEU: la ejecución va avanzando, pero llega la hora de la verdad. CaixaBank Research (2026)
  3. Los fondos europeos de recuperación explican entre el 10% y el 14% del crecimiento del PIB entre 2021 y 2025. Europa Press / Bolsamanía (2026)
  4. Banco de España vincula la reforma laboral con una mayor productividad en empresas con contratos temporales. Europa Press / Bolsamanía (2026)
  5. España se queda sin chips: el pinchazo de los fondos europeos. El Independiente (2026)
  6. Opinion 09/2026 concerning the proposal for a regulation establishing the European Fund for 2028-2034. European Court of Auditors (2026)

Get the week's articles by email