EuropeInterpretation
Draghi vs Letta: scale or market? Two reports for Europe's economy, and what Spain should take
Draghi wants scale, Letta wants a finished single market. Where the two 2024 reports agree, where they split, and a radical-centre way to combine them for Spain.
In short
The Draghi report (The Future of European Competitiveness, September 2024) and the Letta report (Much More Than a Market, April 2024) agree that Europe's market is fragmented in finance, energy and telecoms and that firms need room to grow. Draghi leans on scale through industrial policy, merger rules that weigh innovation and joint EU funding; Letta leans on completing the market, warns against using competition policy to engineer outcomes and adds a freedom to stay for lagging regions. A radical-centre reading lets firms reach scale through the market first, funds jointly only European public goods with measurable targets, and pairs integration with services in the regions that could lose people. By July 2026 only 16% of the Draghi measures tracked by EPIC were fully implemented.
Key points
- Draghi wrote no chapter on the single market because, he said, the Letta report had already analysed it systematically; the two reports share the diagnosis of a market fragmented in finance, energy and telecoms.
- Draghi puts more weight on scale through policy: merger reviews that assess future innovation, wider IPCEIs and some joint funding of European public goods.
- Letta warns that the EU should not use competition policy to engineer market outcomes, says not every firm needs to be bigger, and proposes a State aid contribution mechanism and a freedom to stay.
- The Commission's draft merger guidelines of 30 April 2026 treat scale, innovation and resilience as possible pro-competitive factors; the final text is expected by the end of 2026.
- By July 2026, EPIC counted 16% of tracked Draghi measures fully implemented and 26% partially; the IMF estimates internal EU trade costs equal to a 44% tariff on manufactures and 110% on services.
In 2024 Europe received two reports on its economy within five months of each other. Enrico Letta's Much More Than a Market went to EU leaders in April, prepared under the Belgian, Spanish and Hungarian trio presidency of the Council. Mario Draghi's The Future of European Competitiveness followed in September. We explained each on its own, Draghi here and Letta here. Read side by side, they look like one argument written by two people with different instincts about how firms get big.
Start with how much they share. Draghi's report has no chapter on the single market, and it says why: the Letta report had already analysed the problem systematically, so Draghi scatters proposals through his sector chapters and takes Letta's work as the base. Both men see a market that stopped halfway. Letta's story is that finance, electronic communications and energy were deliberately left out of the single market three decades ago, and that this is a primary reason for Europe's fall in competitiveness. Draghi cites an estimate that remaining trade frictions leave around 10% of potential GDP on the table. Both want European savings to fund European firms. And on telecoms they say almost the same thing: Draghi recommends defining telecoms markets at EU level and giving innovation and investment more weight when mergers are cleared, and Letta writes that once the European market is treated as the relevant one, market forces can drive consolidation and growth in scale.
Where they pull apart
The gap opens on the tools. Draghi trusts policy to help build scale. He wants merger evaluations to ask how a deal affects future innovation, Important Projects of Common European Interest extended to all forms of innovation, and some joint funding of European public goods such as breakthrough innovation, with defence and cross-border grids added if the political conditions are met. He also sets rules for his own industrial policy, and they are good ones: back sectors, never single companies, evaluate support continuously, name the market failure, and keep competition at the centre, because he calls the evidence that it drives productivity overwhelming.
Letta is warier about the state choosing size. He writes that "the EU should not use competition policy to engineer a specific market outcome", that not every European company or market needs to be bigger, and that the link between large and small firms is the bedrock of Europe's social market economy. His worry about subsidies is concrete. The relaxation of State aid after recent crises has distorted competition, and over time it favours the countries with the most fiscal space. His answer is to enforce national aid more strictly and to require member states to put part of their national subsidies into pan-European projects, a State aid contribution mechanism. Letta also floats EU borrowing for public goods such as energy, digital and defence infrastructure, so the split on money is one of emphasis.
The deeper difference is who the market is for. Draghi writes for Europe's competitiveness against the US and China. Letta writes as well for the roughly 135 million Europeans living in places that have fallen behind, and proposes a freedom to stay, with good public services in every region so that moving is a choice.
What has happened since
Brussels has taken from both. The Competitiveness Compass of January 2025 followed Draghi, and a new single market strategy followed Letta. On 30 April 2026 the Commission published draft merger guidelines that describe how mergers may strengthen the scale, competitiveness and resilience of European firms and open the door to more efficiency arguments, which Cleary Gottlieb reads as answering Draghi's call for forward-looking merger control. Teresa Ribera, the Executive Vice-President for competition, insisted the purpose stays the same: protecting competitive markets. The Commission says it will finalise the review in the last quarter of 2026.
Delivery is slower than the documents. A Banco de España analysis from September 2026, using the EPIC Draghi Observatory, finds that by July 2026 16% of the tracked measures were fully implemented, 26% partially and 42% were under way with no binding rule yet in force. Energy, one of the highest-impact areas, stood at about 1%. Defence jumped from 22% to 53% in under a year once the urgency was felt. The author's finding that matters most for this debate is that 53% of Draghi's 176 proposals need no new public money, including every measure on financing and competition. The main obstacle, he concludes, is getting 27 governments to agree.
The IMF has put numbers on the market side. Its November 2025 note on Europe estimates intra-EU trade costs equivalent to a 44% tariff on manufactures and 110% on services, and finds that halving the gaps in national policy and in EU barriers to trade and labour mobility would raise EU productivity by 8.7%. It also finds that some low-density regions could lose productivity as workers move to the hubs, and recommends support for lagging regions and domestic reforms brought forward there.
A radical-centre combination, applied to Spain
Spain needs both reports and in a particular order. The Banco de España finds that Spanish firms average 8.8 employees against 12.1 in the EU. They are born at the same size, about two employees, and five years later the EU average is around 17 and the Spanish one around 12. Those firms need a bigger market more than they need a champion picked for them in Madrid or Brussels, which is the path our growth path exercise follows step by step.
So scale should come through the market first. Spain's priorities in Brussels should be the services barriers, recognised qualifications, an EU-level telecoms market, the savings and investments union and the 28th regime, all of which cost little public money. The new merger guidelines should give room to deals that build European scale where the European market is the real one, and keep Letta's guard against firms growing by smothering rivals. Joint money should go only to European public goods, cross-border grids and breakthrough research above all, each with a target, a deadline and a public scorecard, which is what Draghi asked for in Brussels in September 2025 when he called for dated deliverables and accountability.
The left's contribution is the condition that makes this hold politically. The IMF's own model says a bigger market pulls workers towards dense hubs, and Spain has many thinly populated provinces. A freedom to stay means the integration agenda comes with schools, clinics, broadband and transport in Teruel, Soria or Jaén, paid for through budgets that grow with the activity integration creates. A young founder there should be able to sell in Lyon and raise money in Milan from home, and with that the bigger market works for her too.
Questions and answers
What is the difference between the Draghi report and the Letta report?
Both diagnose a fragmented European market. Draghi's report (September 2024) focuses on competitiveness and scale, with industrial policy, merger rules that weigh innovation and some joint EU funding. Letta's report (April 2024) focuses on completing the single market in finance, energy and telecoms, adding a fifth freedom for knowledge and a freedom to stay for people in lagging regions.
Do Draghi and Letta agree on European champions?
Partly. Both want telecoms markets defined at EU level so that operators can consolidate and invest. Letta adds that not all companies need to be bigger, that Europe's mix of large and small firms must be preserved and that competition policy should not be used to engineer outcomes.
How much of the Draghi report has been implemented?
According to the EPIC Draghi Observatory, cited by the Banco de España in September 2026, 16% of tracked measures were fully implemented by July 2026, 26% partially and 42% were under way. Energy was the weakest area, at about 1%.
What do the Draghi and Letta reports mean for Spain?
Spanish firms average 8.8 employees against 12.1 in the EU and grow less after they are born, so removing barriers to selling, hiring and raising money across the EU matters a great deal. Spain also has many low-density regions, which makes Letta's freedom to stay a practical condition for integration.
Sources
- The future of European competitiveness. Part A: A competitiveness strategy for Europe. European Commission (2024)
- Much more than a market: Speed, Security, Solidarity. Institut Jacques Delors (Enrico Letta) (2024)
- The Draghi report, two years on: what has been achieved?. Banco de España (2026)
- Regional Economic Outlook Notes, Europe: Making European Reforms a Success on the Ground. International Monetary Fund (2025)
- EC Announces Wide-Ranging Reform of Merger Guidelines. Cleary Gottlieb (2026)
- El tamaño sí importa. El reto del crecimiento de las empresas españolas. Banco de España (2025)