MigrationInterpretation
Banishing xenophobic rhetoric: immigration, crime and jobs in Spain with the data
Foreign nationals are convicted at 2.5 times the Spanish rate. Age, sex, cities and residence explain much of it, and jobs data show no displacement.
In short
INE figures for 2025 show foreign nationals convicted at 15.3 per 1,000 adults against 6.1 for Spanish nationals, a gap that a 2026 UC3M study halves once age and sex are taken into account, with no link between a province's share of immigrants or irregular residents and its crime. On jobs, the Banco de España finds no statistically significant effect on the employment rate of Spanish-born workers. The radical-centre answer is to refuse collective blame, punish every crime swiftly with the expulsion the Penal Code already provides for foreigners given more than a year in prison, and have the state publish the full figures, standardised and in context, every year.
Key points
- In 2025 Spain's courts convicted 306,237 adults; 70.2% had Spanish nationality. The rate per 1,000 adults was 6.1 for Spanish nationals and 15.3 for foreign nationals, 2.5 times higher (INE).
- A 2026 UC3M study of 5.5 million convictions finds that comparing people of the same age and sex halves the gap, and that a province's share of immigrants or of irregular residents shows no link with crime.
- Rates vary widely by nationality, and conviction data record nationality but not residence, so tourists and non-resident criminal networks count towards foreigners' rates.
- The Banco de España finds no statistically significant effect of immigration on the employment rate of Spanish-born workers, and native wages have fared much the same in provinces with more and fewer immigrants.
- Our proposal: refuse collective blame, enforce Article 89 of the Penal Code swiftly, and publish every year an official data book on crime and work by nationality, standardised by age and sex.
When Miriam González launched Democracia 21 in Madrid on 10 October 2026, she put a short line in the middle of her migration section: xenophobic rhetoric has to go. In our overview of the speech we read it together with the party's other two migration ideas, immigration as an asset and a state in control. This piece takes the line at its word and does the work it implies: look at what Spain's official figures say about immigration and crime, and about jobs, and then work out how a politician answers people's worries without blaming a whole group of neighbours.
Convictions by nationality, honestly
The INE's latest conviction statistics, published in July 2026, cover 2025. Spain's courts recorded 306,237 adults with final sentences, 0.2% fewer than the year before. Seven in ten, 70.2%, had Spanish nationality. Per 1,000 residents aged 18 and over, the rate was 6.1 for Spanish nationals and 15.3 for foreign nationals, two and a half times higher. Among minors aged 14 to 17 it was 5.6 against 10.2. Those are the numbers, and anyone who wants a serious conversation starts by saying them out loud.
The same release shows why a raw rate needs context. Convictions are overwhelmingly male (80%), and the rate peaks at 14.4 per 1,000 among people aged 21 to 30. Spain's foreign population, 7.5 million people on 1 October 2026 according to the INE's latest population figures, is younger than the Spanish one and more often male.
The most thorough Spanish work on this is a 2026 study by Jesús Javier Sánchez Barricarte of Universidad Carlos III, published in the sociology journal REIS, which goes through more than 5.5 million offences with final convictions between 2007 and 2023. When he compares people of the same age and sex, the gap between Spanish and foreign nationals halves. What then predicts crime across provinces is urbanisation and the average age of the population; a province's share of immigrants shows no link once those are accounted for. Irregular status shows none either: between 2017 and 2023 the share of irregular foreign residents rose by 345% while the standardised conviction rate of foreigners fell by 2%.
The study is just as clear on the rest. Rates vary enormously by nationality. Balkan nationals are convicted at around nine times the Spanish rate, Algerians at five times and Ecuadorians at three, while Indian, Chinese, Filipino and Pakistani nationals sit below the Spanish rate. Conviction records note nationality and leave out residence, so tourists and members of transnational gangs who never lived here count towards "foreigners". White-collar crime, more common among natives, is under-recorded. And the author flags real, worrying differences in femicide and sexual offences, which he links to attitudes towards women in some countries of origin. On terrorism, he notes that more than half of those arrested between 2004 and 2023 were born in Spain.
Meanwhile the Interior Ministry's first-quarter 2026 crime balance puts conventional crime at 40.5 offences per 1,000 inhabitants, in the lowest band of its historical series, in a country with a record number of residents born abroad.
Hein de Haas, whose How Migration Really Works we explained yesterday, reads the European evidence the same way. In a 2025 interview he says the overall effect of immigration on crime is very small and usually insignificant, that newcomers tend to be less criminal than natives with similar education because they came to work, and that the risk lies in segregation: children of immigrants shut out of work for years, especially after a recession.
Jobs and wages
On work, the Banco de España has done the heavy lifting, and our piece on immigration as an asset sets it out in full. The short version from its 2025 Annual Report: using provincial data since 1999, the bank estimates that the rise in immigration has had no statistically significant effect on the employment rate of Spanish-born workers, who have moved towards services while newcomers fill jobs in farming, industry and construction. A first look at wages finds that native pay has fared much the same in provinces that received more immigrants and in those that received fewer.
The OECD's International Migration Outlook 2025 points to where the real labour problem lies. Across member countries immigrants' employment rate in 2024 was 70.9% against 72.1% for the native-born, and newly arrived immigrants earned 34% less than natives, a gap that narrowed to 21% after five years. That is a story of people working hard for less, and a good reason to enforce labour law on every employer.
Answering the worry without xenophobia
The worry is real and it deserves an answer. In the CIS barometer of October 2026, immigration was the second national problem, named by 20.9% of respondents, far behind housing at 55.7%, as Onda Vasca reported. On the list of problems that affect people personally, the top three were housing, the economy and health. De Haas adds that most people hold mixed views on migration and that politicians cherry-pick the facts that suit them.
So here is our answer. From the left we take something every public figure owes the country: equal dignity, and a flat refusal to blame Moroccans, Romanians or Latin Americans as a group for what individuals did. From the liberal and conservative tradition we take the rule of law, applied firmly and to everyone. Crimes get punished quickly, whoever commits them. And Article 89 of the Penal Code already says that a prison sentence of more than one year imposed on a foreign national is replaced by expulsion, with a ban on returning for five to ten years, unless the judge finds it disproportionate given the person's roots in Spain. Applying that rule promptly and consistently is part of fighting xenophobia, because it shows people the system works.
The third piece belongs to neither camp. Rumour grows in the gaps between statistics, and both sides use the gaps. Spain should publish an official yearly data book, released on a fixed date by the INE with Interior and Social Security: convictions and arrests by nationality, raw and standardised by age and sex, with residence status recorded; offence types, including sexual offences and gender violence; employment, wages and contributions by nationality and years in Spain; and expulsions ordered and carried out under Article 89. Yascha Mounk, whose The Great Experiment we explained last month, pictures a diverse democracy as a public park with ground rules that are clearly enforced for everyone. Publishing the figures, the uncomfortable ones included, is how citizens get to see those rules at work, and it leaves the xenophobic speech with very little to stand on.
Questions and answers
Do immigrants commit more crime in Spain?
Foreign nationals are convicted at a higher raw rate: 15.3 per 1,000 adults in 2025 against 6.1 for Spanish nationals, according to the INE. A 2026 study by Jesús Javier Sánchez Barricarte (UC3M) finds the gap halves when people of the same age and sex are compared, varies widely by nationality, and is inflated by convictions of non-residents. Provinces with more immigrants show no higher crime once urbanisation and age are taken into account.
Does irregular immigration increase crime in Spain?
The UC3M study finds no association. Between 2017 and 2023 the share of irregular foreign residents rose by 345% while the standardised conviction rate of foreigners fell by 2%.
Do immigrants take jobs from Spaniards?
The Banco de España's 2025 Annual Report estimates that the rise in immigration has had no statistically significant effect on the employment rate of Spanish-born workers, who have moved towards services. Native wages have fared much the same in provinces that received more immigrants and in those that received fewer.
Can a foreigner convicted of a crime be expelled from Spain?
Yes. Article 89 of the Penal Code says prison sentences of more than one year imposed on a foreign national are replaced by expulsion, with a ban on returning for five to ten years. The judge can order part of the sentence served first, and must refuse expulsion when it would be disproportionate given the person's roots in Spain.
Sources
- Estadística de la Población Condenada: Adulta / Menor de edad. Año 2025. Instituto Nacional de Estadística (2026)
- Un estudio de la UC3M analiza los niveles de delincuencia por nacionalidad (Sánchez Barricarte, REIS 195). Universidad Carlos III de Madrid (2026)
- Annual Report 2025 (chapter 1: immigration and the labour market). Banco de España (2026)
- Migration to OECD countries fell slightly last year, especially in Europe (on the International Migration Outlook 2025). Anadolu Agency (2025)
- The real migration debate we need. Hein de Haas, How Migration Really Works (2025)
- Yascha Mounk explores diverse democracies at SNF Agora event. The Johns Hopkins News-Letter (2022)