MigrationInterpretation
Returns that happen: what Sweden, Germany and the Netherlands do, and the new EU return rule
Spain enforced about one return order in ten in 2025; Sweden, six in ten. What works, what the new EU Return Regulation changes, and a plan for Spain.
In short
In 2025 Spain issued 53,700 orders to leave and returned 5,705 people to third countries, about 11%, against roughly 29% across the EU, 53% in Germany and 61% in Sweden on Eurostat's figures. The countries that do better combine fast decisions, well-paid voluntary return with reintegration support, enforcement as a backstop and steady relations with countries of origin. The new EU Return Regulation, adopted in October 2026, adds a European Return Order, longer entry bans and return hubs. The radical-centre answer for Spain is a return system judged by its speed and its share of voluntary departures, which makes the legal channels credible.
Key points
- Eurostat: in 2025 Spain ordered 53,700 people to leave and returned 5,705 to third countries; the EU figures were 486,705 and 139,270.
- Germany carried out 22,787 deportations in 2025 and saw 16,576 assisted voluntary departures under REAG/GARP, with €1,000 start-up help per adult.
- In the Netherlands just over 60% of verified departures in 2025 were independent and 40% forced; the Dutch return service notes that the longer procedures last, the smaller the chance of departure.
- Spain's prosecution service names lack of documents and limited consular cooperation as the main reason expulsions fail.
- Regulation (EU) 2026/2280, adopted on 7 October 2026, replaces the 2008 Return Directive, with a departure period of up to 30 days, entry bans of up to 10 years and most rules applying from 17 October 2027.
Every immigration system makes a promise in two directions. People with a right to stay get to stay, and people without one leave. Spain keeps the first promise reasonably well and barely keeps the second, and that weakens public trust in the whole system, legal channels included. Making the State decide who comes in and who leaves was one of the problems Miriam González put at the centre of Democracia 21's launch, which we mapped in our overview; we sketched a yearly plan by channel in an earlier piece. This one looks at the leaving half.
The gap in numbers
Eurostat's latest data, for 2025, record 53,700 orders to leave issued in Spain and 5,705 people returned to a country outside the EU. That is about 11%. Across the EU the figures were 486,705 orders and 139,270 returns, close to 29%. Germany returned 29,295 people against 55,240 orders, about 53%, and Sweden 11,250 against 18,340, about 61%. The ratio is rough, because a return in one year can follow an order from an earlier one, and many people leave without anyone recording it. Still, a gap of five or six times between Spain and Sweden is a difference in the system.
Spain's own prosecution service explains part of it. In its report on 2025 it names the lack of documents and limited consular cooperation as the main reason expulsions fail: Morocco requires an original valid passport, and Algeria barely issues travel documents for expulsions at all.
What three countries do
Germany shows that both tools can grow together. The Act to improve repatriation, in force since February 2024, lengthened pre-departure custody from ten to 28 days and widened police powers in shared accommodation, while also guaranteeing a court-appointed lawyer in detention cases. Deportations rose from 12,945 in 2022 to 22,787 in 2025, according to the Federal Agency for Civic Education. At the same time, assisted voluntary departures under the REAG/GARP programme rose by about 60% in 2025, to 16,576, with start-up help of €1,000 per adult and €500 per child.
The Netherlands has a dedicated Repatriation and Departure Service whose motto is to leave independently where possible and by force where necessary. In 2025 just over 7,160 people verifiably left, a 23% rise on 2024, and just over 60% of them left on their own. Another 5,440 left without supervision to unknown destinations, which is why the Dutch rate looks low in Eurostat's table. The service's own report contains the single most useful finding for Spain: the average time from registration to an asylum decision was about 67 weeks, and the longer procedures last, the smaller the chance of departure. A study by the Dutch justice ministry's research centre found that legally binding bilateral readmission agreements raise return rates, while agreements signed at EU level showed no demonstrable effect; the return service invests in personal relationships with authorities in countries of origin.
Sweden has made returns the main priority of its Migration Agency for 2026 and passed a law, applying from July 2026, that obliges agencies such as the employment service and the tax agency to report people who may lack the right to stay. Its rate was already the highest of the three before that law.
The new European rule
On 7 October 2026 the EU adopted Regulation (EU) 2026/2280, which replaces the 2008 Return Directive with rules that apply directly in every member state. A return decision sets a departure period of up to 30 days. Entry bans can last up to ten years, or twenty for duly substantiated reasons, and can be shortened for people who leave voluntarily. Returnees have a duty to cooperate, to stay reachable and to hand over identity documents. States must offer counselling and return and reintegration programmes. A European Return Order will let one country's decision travel with the person, and states may choose to recognise each other's decisions. Return hubs in third countries are allowed under agreements that respect human rights standards, including non-refoulement. Most of the regulation applies from 17 October 2027, which gives Spain eleven months to get ready.
A return system for Spain
David Miller argues that a democracy may decide its own membership, and Martin Ruhs shows that openness and rights involve trade-offs that a country has to choose openly. Both arguments lead to the same practical point: a system that admits people generously through legal channels needs a credible exit for those who have no right to stay, or the public stops supporting the channels.
The radical-centre position puts the left's insistence on dignity, the liberal insistence on enforcement and the Dutch lesson about speed into one design. Measure the system by two numbers, published every quarter: the time from application to final decision, and the share of departures that are voluntary. Decide asylum claims in months, with real legal aid, so that a refusal comes while a voluntary return is still realistic. Offer counselling from the first refusal and a reintegration package on the German model, generous enough to compete with staying in the shadows. Keep forced removal for those who refuse, under judicial control and with no return hubs for children. And build ties with Morocco, Senegal, Mauritania and Algeria country by country, with visas for students and workers, investment and documents for returns negotiated as a single relationship, because the Dutch evidence says working relationships deliver where EU-level paper agreements do not. Spain can arrive at October 2027 with a return service that matches its legal channels.
Questions and answers
What is the EU return rate?
It is the share of people ordered to leave who actually leave. On Eurostat's 2025 data, 139,270 third-country nationals were returned to a third country against 486,705 orders, about 29%. The ratio is approximate, because returns in one year can follow orders from earlier years.
How many return orders does Spain enforce?
Very few. Eurostat records 53,700 orders to leave and 5,705 returns to third countries for Spain in 2025, roughly 11%, one of the lowest rates in the EU. Spain's prosecution service blames missing documents and limited consular cooperation, especially from Algeria.
What is the new EU Return Regulation?
Regulation (EU) 2026/2280, adopted on 7 October 2026, replaces the 2008 Return Directive with directly applicable rules. It creates a European Return Order, lets states recognise each other's return decisions, sets a departure period of up to 30 days, entry bans of up to 10 years (20 for substantiated reasons), duties for returnees to cooperate and the option of return hubs in third countries. Most of it applies from 17 October 2027.
What makes returns work?
The evidence points to fast asylum decisions, early counselling and voluntary return with reintegration support, which is cheaper and works better for the returnee, plus strong economic and political ties with countries of origin. A Dutch government study found legally binding bilateral readmission agreements raise return rates, while EU-level agreements showed no demonstrable effect.
Sources
- Regulation (EU) 2026/2280 on a common system for the return of third-country nationals staying illegally in the Union. EUR-Lex (2026)
- Third country nationals returned following an order to leave, annual data (migr_eirtn). Eurostat (2026)
- Third country nationals ordered to leave, annual data (migr_eiord). Eurostat (2026)
- Abschiebungen und Dublin-Überstellungen. Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (2026)
- Stand van de uitvoering 2025. Dienst Terugkeer en Vertrek (DTenV) (2026)
- La Fiscalía detectó trabas de Marruecos y Argelia para ejecutar expulsiones en 2025. Onda Vasca (2026)