Economy & workInterpretation

Taxes for public services: where Spanish public spending goes and how to cut patronage

Spain spends less than the EU average on health and education, and a third of its tenders get a single bid. Where the money goes and how to keep it for services.

Comic illustration: at El Mercado, Marco lifts a ledger, Lucía points with a coin and Carmen holds a magnifier beside a funnel that pours gold coins straight into a teal clinic box, with the side leaks dotted and closed off, while Punto in a fedora perches on Marco's ledger.

In short

Spain's public spending was 45.5% of GDP in 2024, below the EU's 48.8%, and it spends less than the EU average on health (6.5% against 7.3%) and education (4.1% against 4.7%), while interest on the debt takes more. The patronage problem lives in how money is spent: subsidies that are rarely evaluated, public tenders where a third of contracts get a single bid, and political appointments. A radical-centre answer keeps taxes for services by evaluating every programme, opening procurement to real competition, hiring by merit and publishing what each euro achieves.

Key points

  • Eurostat, 2024: Spanish general government spending was 45.5% of GDP (EU 48.8%); health 6.5% (EU 7.3%), education 4.1% (EU 4.7%), social protection 18.7% (EU 19.5%), interest 2.5% (EU 1.9%).
  • European Commission, 2024: 33% of Spanish public contracts drew a single bid (typical EU country 28%), and only 19% were awarded on price alone (54%).
  • AIReF found about €14 billion a year in subsidies with almost no strategy or evaluation of results; by 2025 the government had implemented 217 of its 357 spending-review recommendations and rejected 82.
  • Spain's ministries employed 959 political advisers in January 2026, according to the official public-employment bulletin.
  • The fix is in how money is spent: rules, competition, merit and published results.

At its launch Democracia 21 promised that Spaniards' taxes would pay for public services and stop feeding patronage networks. Its website puts the idea under a heading that promises an end to clientelist networks: fewer political advisers, no party-card appointments, merit and capacity in every post (see our overview of the party's proposals). It is a popular promise because most Spaniards suspect their taxes leak. The data on where the money goes helps put the suspicion in the right place.

Where the money goes

Eurostat's latest breakdown by function, for 2024, puts Spanish general government spending at 45.5% of GDP, against 48.8% in the EU. In 2025 the gap was similar, 45.3% against 49.4%. Spain is a lower-spending state than the European average.

The biggest item is social protection, mainly pensions, at 18.7% of GDP and 41% of all spending, slightly below the EU's 19.5%. Health takes 6.5% of GDP, against 7.3% in the EU. Education takes 4.1%, against 4.7%. General public services take 5.8%, close to the EU's 6.0%, but inside that heading interest on the public debt costs Spain 2.5% of GDP, against 1.9% in the EU, almost €40 billion in 2024. Economic affairs, which includes transport, energy and subsidies to business, takes 5.1%.

So the big lines of the budget are services and pensions, and on the services people use most Spain spends less than its neighbours. A government that wants better health and schools has to protect that money. The leaks are in how it is spent, and they show up in three places.

Where patronage hides

The first is subsidies. In 2019 the independent fiscal authority, AIReF, reviewed about €14 billion a year in grants from ministries, regions and local governments. It found plans with virtually no strategic character, almost no evaluation of results and little coordination between administrations, and it recommended reforming the general subsidies law, adding sanctions and building a system with result indicators. A grant that nobody evaluates is the easiest tool for rewarding friends, because nobody can show it failed.

The second is procurement. The European Commission's Single Market Scoreboard for 2024 found that 33% of Spanish public contracts received a single bid, above the 28% of a typical EU country and well above the 20% the Commission treats as a warning sign. Eight per cent were awarded without any call for bids. Only 19% were decided on price alone, against 54% in the typical member state, which leaves more room for discretionary scoring. Decisions took 110 days, against 74, and small firms won 55% of contracts, against 71%. A market where one bidder turns up and the criteria are soft is a market where connections pay.

The third is jobs. The official bulletin on public employment counted 959 political advisers in central government ministries in January 2026, 490 of them in the ministry that includes the Prime Minister's office. Advisers are a small part of the public payroll, but every one of them is chosen by loyalty, and the same logic extends to the boards of public companies and agencies. Spain has cut that layer before: by the end of 2014 the CORA reform reported the net elimination of 2,029 public bodies, most of them in regional and local government.

The good news is that Spain already has the tool to check its spending. Since 2018 AIReF has run spending reviews of subsidies, hospital spending, labour market policies, hiring incentives and more. The Treasury's 2025 follow-up report says 217 of AIReF's 357 recommendations have been implemented, 58 are in progress and 82 have been rejected; of the 61 from the third phase, only 8 have been applied.

Rules, competition and delivery

Friedrich Hayek, in The Constitution of Liberty, argued that freedom depends on general rules known in advance, and that discretionary power is where arbitrary treatment begins. That is the market-liberal half of the answer to patronage. Open every contract to real competition, give price and measurable quality more weight in tenders, cut discretionary grants in favour of rules that anyone who qualifies can claim, and fill posts by merit. The left brings the other half: these taxes pay for the health centres, schools and care that people with less money rely on most, and Spain spends less than its neighbours on exactly those. Cutting patronage is how you defend public services, and every euro recovered should stay in them.

Jennifer Pahlka, in Recoding America, adds the piece that fits neither camp. Rules alone produce paperwork; what matters is whether the service gets delivered. Her answer is to build delivery capacity inside the state and judge programmes by what they achieve for the people using them. Applied to Spanish spending, that means every programme above a threshold gets an outcome target, an independent evaluation and a public counter showing what it achieved. The comply-or-explain rule already exists; the explanation for each rejected AIReF recommendation should be defended in Parliament, and the Treasury should publish each year how much money moved from programmes that failed to services that work. Procurement data goes online in real time, contract by contract, with the number of bidders. And the regions, which spend most of the money and employ most public staff, sign up to the same counters.

Clientelism thrives in the dark, as we argued in our pieces on what political clientelism is and how it holds back growth in southern Europe. Spending that is measured, competed for and published leaves it very little room, and taxpayers can see their money arrive where it was promised.

Questions and answers

Where does Spanish public spending go?

In 2024, according to Eurostat, Spanish general government spent 45.5% of GDP. The largest item was social protection, mostly pensions, at 18.7% of GDP and 41% of the total, followed by health at 6.5%, general public services (including 2.5% of GDP in interest) at 5.8%, economic affairs at 5.1% and education at 4.1%.

Does Spain spend more than the European average?

No. Spanish public spending was 45.5% of GDP in 2024 against 48.8% in the EU, and 45.3% against 49.4% in 2025. Spain spends less than the EU average on health, education and social protection, and more on interest.

What is clientelism in public spending?

It is the use of public money and jobs to reward supporters: discretionary subsidies, contracts steered to friendly firms, and posts filled by political loyalty. Its signs in the data are unevaluated programmes, tenders with a single bidder and large numbers of political appointees.

What is the AIReF spending review?

A series of evaluations of large public spending programmes carried out by Spain's independent fiscal authority, AIReF, since 2018, covering subsidies, labour market policies, hospital spending, hiring incentives and more. The government reports each year on which recommendations it adopts, under a comply-or-explain principle.

Sources

  1. General government expenditure by function (COFOG), gov_10a_exp. Eurostat (2026)
  2. Single Market Scoreboard: Spain. European Commission (2025)
  3. Informe sobre el grado de implementación de las recomendaciones del Spending Review 2025. Ministerio de Hacienda (2025)
  4. La AIReF critica la falta de coordinación sobre 14.000 millones de euros en subvenciones. Valencia Plaza (2019)
  5. Boletín estadístico del personal al servicio de las administraciones públicas, enero 2026. Ministerio para la Transformación Digital y de la Función Pública (2026)
  6. Limpieza política radical. Democracia 21 (2026)

Get the week's articles by email