Democracy & institutionsProposal
A delivery unit for Spain: Pahlka and Flyvbjerg at the Moncloa
Blair had one, France publishes one, Spain counts promises. A small delivery unit at the Moncloa with public clocks, honest forecasts and an end date.
In short
A delivery unit is a small team at the head of government that tracks a handful of priorities against public measures and helps departments unblock them; the UK created the first in 2001 and some 25 countries have copied it. The radical-centre proposal for Spain is a unit at the Presidency with at most five priorities, each measured from the citizen's side on a public clock, a reference-class forecast for every large project before it is approved, and service teams of designers and engineers working with front-line staff. Each priority team closes when its goal is met, and the unit itself lapses with the legislature unless the next government renews it.
Key points
- The UK's Prime Minister's Delivery Unit was created in June 2001 under Michael Barber to track 17 public service targets across four departments, with regular stocktakes chaired by Tony Blair.
- The Institute for Government counts delivery units supporting heads of government in some 25 countries and says they need a well-defined remit and strong political backing.
- France has published a baromètre of priority policies since January 2021, giving each a starting value, a current value and a target.
- Spain's Cumpliendo report tracks commitments made: 1,513 by December 2022, 66.8% fulfilled. It records promises kept, and leaves out what citizens experience at the counter.
- Our proposal: at most five priorities, public monthly clocks, a reference-class check on every large project, service teams with front-line staff, and an end date for every priority team.
Every Spanish government arrives at the Moncloa with a programme, and the programme then disappears into ministries, regions, contracts and calls for tender. Two of the problems Miriam González set out at the launch of Democracia 21 on 10 October 2026, which we mapped in our overview, point at that gap: public services that work by design, without depending on the goodwill of doctors, nurses, teachers and police, and a systematic review of outdated rules and needless procedures. Both need someone at the centre of government whose only job is to see that a few things actually happen. This week closes with a proposal for that someone: a small delivery unit at the Presidency, built with the tools of Jennifer Pahlka and Bent Flyvbjerg.
What Barber built, and what went wrong with it
The model is British. A few days after Tony Blair's re-election in June 2001, Michael Barber set up the Prime Minister's Delivery Unit in the Cabinet Office. According to the Centre for Public Impact, it followed 17 public service targets across four departments, Home Office, Health, Education and Transport, with a delivery plan for each and regular stocktakes that Blair chaired himself, sometimes for half a day a week. Patients waiting a year or more for surgery fell from over 40,000 in 2001 to under 10,000 in 2003. The Institute for Government credits the unit with helping meet targets on school class sizes and NHS waiting times.
Its weaknesses are just as instructive. The IfG's Rhys Clyne notes that it became less effective once its resources were spread across too many priorities, that Gordon Brown moved it to the Treasury in 2007 and weakened it, and that some waiting-time targets were met by cancelling other appointments. When Boris Johnson revived it in 2021, after a review by Barber, Clyne warned that a remit like "levelling up" was far too broad. A 2017 IfG report by Jen Gold counted delivery units supporting heads of government in some 25 countries and many others closing after their launch fanfare, and concluded that they need a well-defined remit and strong political backing.
The same years produced a second British invention. Martha Lane Fox's eleven-page review of 2010 led to the Government Digital Service, and the Economics Observatory tells how a 15-person team of user researchers, designers, developers and product managers built an early version of GOV.UK in 12 weeks for £261,000. GOV.UK replaced more than 2,500 government websites from October 2012, and GDS gained the power to stop a new online service going live if it failed the service standard. Barber's unit watched the numbers from above. GDS put people who could build things inside the service.
France has added a third piece, the public dashboard. Since January 2021 its baromètre des résultats de l'action publique has shown, for some thirty priority policies at first, a starting value, the current value and a target, with the data published openly by Etalab.
Spain has its own version of the centre's scorecard. The Presidency's Cumpliendo report counts the commitments the government has made and how many it has fulfilled: in December 2022, 1,513 commitments and 66.8% fulfilled, with an open data file, a dashboard and a methodology endorsed by a panel of experts. It is a real exercise in transparency, and it measures promises kept. A law passed counts as fulfilled whether or not anyone's wait got shorter. And with fifteen hundred items, nothing in it can be steered from the Moncloa.
The unit we propose
The Oficina de Ejecución de la Presidencia would be small, a few dozen people, reporting directly to the president. At the start of a legislature the government chooses at most five priorities and writes each one through our five-column test: goal, who decides, who implements, who can veto, and how we will know it worked. The last column becomes a public clock measured from the citizen's side: days to resolve a minimum income claim, days to the next appointment at a health centre, days from signature to a company's tax number, months to connect a solar farm to the grid. Every clock goes online monthly, by region where the data allows, in the open format France already uses. Each one carries a guard measure next to it, so that a waiting list cannot shrink by quietly cancelling appointments, the trick that discredited some of Blair's targets. The president chairs a stocktake on each priority every quarter, with the minister and the officials who run it in the room.
Pahlka supplies the second half. In Recoding America she shows good laws breaking at the point of delivery, because the people who could fix the process have no say in it. So each priority gets a service team, hired on merit into the civil service: a product manager, service designers, engineers, a policy official and staff from the front line, the clerks, nurses and inspectors who know where the forms jam. They work inside the ministry or region that owns the service, test changes with real users and are allowed to change the process. When they find a rule in the way, they send it to the productivity commission we proposed on day 29, which reviews it in the open and gives the government a deadline to answer. That is how Democracia 21's two problems meet in one machine: services redesigned by the people who run them, and rules cleared when the redesign hits them, as our piece on public services by design set out for health centres.
Flyvbjerg supplies the gate for big projects. How Big Things Get Done asks governments to plan slowly and build fast, and to estimate each project from the record of similar finished ones, the outside view. In a 2009 paper with Massimo Garbuio and Dan Lovallo he argues that this reference-class forecasting corrects both honest optimism and deliberate underestimates. The unit would hold Spain's reference classes for rail, grids, hospitals and housing, and no project above a set threshold would reach the Consejo de Ministros without a forecast drawn from them, published alongside the promoter's own figures and later compared with the real outcome. Our review of the Next Generation funds showed what happens without that check, with programmes written in months and executed over years.
Built to close
The design contains its own end. Each priority team dissolves when its clock has held the target for two consecutive quarters, and its members go back to their ministries carrying the method with them. The unit itself lapses with the legislature, and the next government revives it only by publishing its own five priorities. That keeps the remit tight, the IfG's first condition, and it keeps the unit from turning into one more layer of the state.
The left contributes the conviction that an active state has to guarantee that services reach people, and that the public servants who run them deserve the training, tools and respect to do it, starting with a seat on the team that redesigns their work. The liberal tradition contributes value for money, results measured in public and the willingness to stop a project or scrap a rule that fails its own test. What fits neither camp is the instrument that binds them: a small unit with published clocks, honest forecasts and service teams on the front line, whose work on each priority ends when that priority is delivered. Cumpliendo can carry on counting commitments, and the five clocks would sit beside it on the Presidency's website, updated every month.
Questions and answers
What is a government delivery unit?
A small team at the centre of government, usually reporting to the prime minister, that tracks a few top priorities against agreed measures, meets regularly with the departments responsible and helps them remove obstacles. The model comes from the UK's Prime Minister's Delivery Unit, set up by Michael Barber for Tony Blair in 2001.
Did Tony Blair's Delivery Unit work?
On its narrow targets, largely yes. The Centre for Public Impact reports that patients waiting a year or more for surgery fell from over 40,000 in 2001 to under 10,000 in 2003, and the Institute for Government credits the unit with helping meet class-size and waiting-time targets. It weakened when its priorities multiplied and when it lost prime-ministerial attention, and some targets were met by cancelling other appointments.
Does Spain have a delivery unit?
Spain has a Presidency report, Cumpliendo, that counts how many government commitments have been fulfilled, with open data and a methodology reviewed by an expert group. It records promises kept. A delivery unit would track a few outcomes as citizens experience them and work with ministries to move them.
What do Pahlka and Flyvbjerg add to the delivery unit model?
Jennifer Pahlka, author of Recoding America, adds in-house teams of designers and engineers who test services with real users and can change the process. Bent Flyvbjerg, co-author of How Big Things Get Done, adds reference-class forecasting: estimating each big project from the record of similar finished ones, and planning slowly before building fast.
Sources
- Prime Minister's Delivery Unit (UK). Centre for Public Impact (2016)
- The new Prime Minister's Delivery Unit needs prime ministerial authority and attention. Institute for Government (2021)
- Tracking delivery: Global trends and warning signs in delivery units. Institute for Government (2017)
- The UK government's digital transformation: how did it come about?. Economics Observatory (2026)
- Baromètre des résultats de l'action publique. data.gouv.fr (Gouvernement français) (2021)
- El Gobierno ya ha cumplido más del 66% de sus compromisos y prevé alcanzar el 73% para el próximo semestre. La Moncloa (2022)