# Mounk and integration: common citizenship without cultural uniformity in Spain's neighbourhoods

> Yascha Mounk's The Great Experiment (2022) argues that diverse democracies succeed when they look like a public park, where people keep their identities and still meet under shared rules, and fail when they drift into a salad bowl of segregated neighbourhoods. Paul Collier's Exodus (2013) adds that integration has a pace, and that it slows when newcomers have little contact with the wider society. Spain, where 20.9% of residents were born abroad in October 2026, has moderate segregation and a serious housing problem. The radical-centre proposal is a neighbourhood contract: mixed housing, shared everyday institutions and funding tied to measured contact, run by town halls with State money.

- URL: https://www.radicalcentre.eu/en/articles/mounk-integration-common-citizenship-neighbourhoods-spain
- Language: en
- Publisher: radical centre / centro radical
- Published: 2026-11-16
- Topic: Migration
- Author: radical centre
- Licence: CC BY 4.0

## Key points

- On 1 October 2026 Spain had 49,935,642 residents, of whom 10,433,091 were born abroad, about 20.9%, according to INE's provisional figures.
- Mounk contrasts the public park, where people can stay among their own or join strangers, with a salad bowl where residential segregation is the norm and friendships across groups are rare.
- Collier argues that integration has an absorption rate and lists the geographical dispersion of migrants among the tools that affect it; critics say he plays down class.
- A study of Madrid found foreign residents' segregation indices below 0.5 and described the city's high-concentration areas as ethnic enclaves rather than ghettos.
- The FOESSA report finds 47.4% of people of immigrant origin in social exclusion, against 15.3% of the native population, with housing as the main driver.

One in five people living in Spain was born in another country. On 1 October 2026, according to INE's provisional figures, the number was 10,433,091 out of 49,935,642, and almost all of the recent population growth came from people born abroad. That makes the question Yascha Mounk asks in The Great Experiment a Spanish one: whether the people who share a country end up seeing each other as strangers or as compatriots. We applied Mounk to Spanish classrooms in [an earlier piece](/en/articles/mounk-common-school-integration-without-uniformity) and explained the book [here](/en/articles/yascha-mounk-the-great-experiment-explained). This proposal takes him to the street and the block. Integration and the State's role in it are among the problems Miriam González raised at the launch of Democracia 21, which we mapped in [our overview](/en/articles/democracia-21-miriam-gonzalez-proposals-radical-centre).

Mounk's image is a public park. As Diana Muir Appelbaum summarises it in the New Rambler Review, in a good park individuals can do things on their own, gather in like-minded groups or join activities with complete strangers, and nobody suffers pervasive discrimination or enmity because of who they are. Mounk sets it against two failures. The melting pot asks newcomers to drop their origins. The darker version of the salad bowl is a society where, in his words as Appelbaum quotes them, residential segregation is the norm and friendships between members of different groups are rare. Appelbaum's objection is the useful one for policymakers: what, beyond good intentions, keeps the park from turning into the segregated bowl? Mounk leans on informal rules and on an everyday cultural patriotism, the love people feel for the city where they grew up and for the sounds and smells of their country, which newcomers can come to share.

Paul Collier, in Exodus, supplies a missing variable: time. In Georgiana Turculet's review for the Central and Eastern European Migration Review, Collier's model holds that a larger diaspora makes new arrivals easier and integration slower, so policy has to keep an equilibrium; he speaks of a cultural absorption rate, and lists the geographical dispersion of migrants and school policies among the tools of integration. His critics, Kenan Malik and Ian Birrell among them, say he reads correlation as causation and ignores class. Both points matter in Spain.

## What Spain's neighbourhoods look like

The good news first. A 2020 study of Madrid in the Anales de Geografía of the Complutense University, using the 2017 register, found that foreign residents made up 20.16% of the city and that segregation indices for the main nationalities stayed below 0.5, from 0.27 for Venezuelans to 0.42 for Ecuadorians. Its conclusion is that segregation in Madrid is fairly moderate, with some neighbourhoods better described as ethnic enclaves than as ghettos. The highest concentration was in San Cristóbal, in Villaverde, at 46.58%, a neighbourhood the authors call one of the most vulnerable in the city, where cheap housing draws low-income residents and local complaints focus on dirt and municipal neglect.

That last detail points to the real problem. The FOESSA report, published by Cáritas in November 2025, finds 47.4% of people of immigrant origin in social exclusion, almost three times the native rate of 15.3%, and calls housing the factor actively reshaping Spain's social structure. It also stresses that exclusion does not originate in immigration, though immigrants suffer some of its worst consequences. In Spain, where you live is decided mainly by what you can pay.

The government's Plan de Integración y Ciudadanía 2026-2030, presented in June 2026, has four axes, 16 measures and more than €500 million in its first year, with action against school segregation and against discrimination in access to housing. It describes no specific neighbourhood programme, and its text does not mention town halls. Catalonia and Barcelona show the tool that is missing: Barcelona's Pla de Barris puts €200 million into 27 neighbourhoods in 2025-2028, and the Catalan neighbourhoods law funds plans in 20 municipalities.

## A neighbourhood contract

The radical-centre proposal combines the left's case for investing where exclusion concentrates, the liberal case for shared rules and free choice, and an idea that belongs to neither: treating everyday contact between groups as something a city can build and measure.

Build the park at street level. The State should fund a neighbourhood contract with town halls in every area where exclusion and recent arrivals concentrate, on the Pla de Barris model, and tie part of the money to results. The money goes to shared everyday institutions where people meet as neighbours: sports clubs, libraries with language classes open to all, after-school activities, local festivals, residents' associations. Mounk's park needs places, and these are the places.

Mix housing at the scale of the block. New public and protected rental housing should be spread across every neighbourhood, with a share reserved in better-off areas, so that no barrio becomes the only place a low-income family can afford. Nobody is moved anywhere: Collier's dispersion works best through the supply of homes, and people stay free to live near family and friends.

Ask for the shared rules plainly. Language classes, civic orientation and the same norms for everyone, explained in the town hall that also fixes the street lighting. That is Mounk's cultural patriotism in practice: the newcomer is invited into the ordinary life of the place.

Measure contact. Each contract should publish a few indicators every year: the mix of pupils in local schools, membership of clubs across origins, residents' trust in neighbours, and the concentration of exclusion. That is Collier's absorption rate turned from a worry into a target. Towns that move the indicators get more money, and the ones that stall get help first.

## FAQ

### What does Yascha Mounk mean by the public park?

In The Great Experiment, Mounk compares a healthy diverse democracy to a public park where individuals can do things alone, gather in like-minded groups or join activities with strangers, and nobody suffers pervasive discrimination for their identity. He contrasts it with a salad bowl in which residential segregation is the norm and friendships between groups are rare.

### How many people born abroad live in Spain?

According to INE's provisional data for 1 October 2026, 10,433,091 of Spain's 49,935,642 residents were born abroad, about 20.9%, and 7,518,237 had foreign nationality. Spain passed ten million foreign-born residents for the first time in January 2026.

### Is there residential segregation of immigrants in Spain?

It exists and is moderate by international standards. A 2020 study of Madrid found segregation indices for the main nationalities between 0.27 and 0.42 and concluded that the areas with high concentrations are better described as ethnic enclaves than as ghettos. The bigger problem is housing exclusion, which FOESSA identifies as the factor reshaping Spain's social structure.

### What is Spain's integration plan?

The Plan de Integración y Ciudadanía 2026-2030, presented in June 2026, has four axes, 16 measures and ten objectives for 2030, with more than €500 million in its first year. It includes action against school segregation and against discrimination in access to housing, and describes no specific neighbourhood programme.

## Sources

- [Let's undo the melting pot (review of The Great Experiment)](https://newramblerreview.com/book-reviews/political-science/let-s-undo-the-melting-pot), New Rambler Review (2022)
- [Exodus: How Migration Is Changing Our World (review by Georgiana Turculet)](https://ceemr.uw.edu.pl/node/181), Central and Eastern European Migration Review (2014)
- [Estadística Continua de Población, 1 de octubre de 2026 (datos provisionales)](https://ine.es/dyngs/Prensa/ECP3T26.htm), INE (2026)
- [Segregación residencial de la población extranjera en Madrid](https://revistas.ucm.es/index.php/AGUC/article/download/72980/4564456555115/4564456601659), Anales de Geografía de la Universidad Complutense (2020)
- [IX Informe FOESSA (nota de prensa)](https://www.caritas.es/main-files/uploads/2025/11/20251105_NdP_IXInformeFOESSA.pdf), Cáritas / Fundación FOESSA (2025)
- [Sánchez presenta el Plan de Integración y Ciudadanía](https://www.lamoncloa.gob.es/presidente/actividades/Paginas/2026/300626-sanchez-plan-integracion-ciudadania.aspx), La Moncloa (2026)
