# Joseph Carens's The Ethics of Immigration explained: membership, time and open borders

> Joseph Carens's The Ethics of Immigration (Oxford University Press, 2013) argues in two stages. First, accepting for argument's sake that states control admissions, it shows that time spent living in a society makes people members, so long-term residents, temporary workers and irregular migrants gain rights that grow with the years, up to citizenship. Second, it argues that freedom and equality, taken seriously, lead to open borders. The radical-centre reading takes the first half as a design rule for Spain: membership measured by a clock, public services walled off from enforcement, and admissions decided openly by the Cortes.

- URL: https://www.radicalcentre.eu/en/articles/joseph-carens-the-ethics-of-immigration-explained
- Language: en
- Publisher: radical centre / centro radical
- Published: 2026-11-16
- Topic: Ideas & history
- Author: radical centre
- Licence: CC BY 4.0

## Key points

- Joseph Carens's The Ethics of Immigration (Oxford University Press, 2013) has two parts, 'Who Belongs?' and 'Who Should Get In?', plus an appendix on presuppositions and political theory.
- In the first part Carens provisionally accepts that states have wide discretion over admissions and argues that, even so, social membership built over years gives residents a moral claim to citizenship.
- Temporary workers get equal working conditions from the start; irregular migrants get basic legal rights and a firewall between public services and immigration enforcement.
- In the second part Carens argues from autonomy and equality of opportunity to a human right to move across borders.
- Spain already lays the first brick of that firewall in health care: since 2018 people without legal residence have a right to care in the same conditions as Spaniards.

Joseph Carens's The Ethics of Immigration, published by Oxford University Press in 2013, is the book most people have in mind when they think of the philosophical case for open borders. That description is accurate and also leaves out the half of the book that matters most for policy. Carens, a political theorist at the University of Toronto, wrote it in two parts with plain titles: "Who Belongs?" and "Who Should Get In?". The first part works inside the world as it is. The second asks what a just world would look like. We have already set Carens against David Miller in [an earlier piece](/en/articles/carens-vs-miller-open-borders-or-communities-that-decide); here we go through the book itself, because a Spanish government could use most of its first part tomorrow. Migration is one of the problems Miriam González raised at the launch of Democracia 21, which we mapped in [our overview](/en/articles/democracia-21-miriam-gonzalez-proposals-radical-centre).

## Who belongs: membership grows with time

Carens begins with a concession. For the whole first part he accepts what he calls the conventional view, that states have considerable discretion over whom they admit. Arash Abizadeh, reviewing the book for Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews, explains why this move is clever: it lets Carens show how much follows from democratic principles even for readers who reject open borders.

The engine of the first part is the social membership norm. A person's moral claim to belong rests on being embedded in a dense network of relationships and associations in a society. Carens finds that idea already at work in birthright citizenship, which we give to children because they will grow up as members. Migrants build the same network, just later. So the longer someone lives in a country, the stronger their claim to stay and, after several years, to citizenship. Carens rejects most of the usual hurdles on the way: civic tests, proof of income, renouncing another nationality. A criminal record serious enough to justify deportation is the exception.

The chapters then run through the categories of people who live in a country without being citizens. Permanent residents should be close to equal with citizens. Temporary workers, Abizadeh notes, should have the same rights to working conditions as everyone else from the first day, and a reciprocity norm gives them access to the social programmes they pay into through contributions; access to the rest comes after several years. Michael Blake, reviewing the book in Ethics & International Affairs, singles out Carens's argument that expelling people who have built their lives in a place destroys value they created, which makes it a graver act than refusing entry in the first place.

Irregular migrants get the chapter people argue about most. They keep basic legal rights, to be paid and to fair working conditions, and Carens adds a firewall: information collected when they see a doctor, enrol a child in school or go to the police may not be handed to immigration enforcement. Without that wall, he argues, the rights exist only on paper. Abizadeh pushes back on two points: a strict firewall could weaken the very state discretion Carens has granted, and it is odd to give an undocumented person a moral claim to citizenship but no right to look for work.

## Who gets in: the open-borders half

The second part drops the concession. Carens looks at ordinary admissions, at refugees, at family reunification, and then makes the case for open borders. Blake summarises the refugee chapter as a call for a more inclusive concept of refugee law and a stronger family reunification regime. On selection, Abizadeh lists what Carens rules out as grounds for exclusion, race, ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation and ideology, and what he allows, poverty and a significant criminal record.

The open-borders argument rests on three grounds. Autonomy comes first: the reasons that make free movement within a country a basic right apply between countries too. Equality of opportunity follows, since restricting movement by citizenship makes life chances depend on a status handed out at birth, which Carens calls a "feudal class privilege". Global economic inequality supplies the third ground. Blake, a long-time critic, says the book persuaded him the overall view hangs together, and still rejects the conclusion: Carens gives no weight, in his reading, to residents' interest in their community's character. An appendix sets out Carens's method, moving between what is feasible now and what justice ultimately requires.

## What Spain can take from it

Spain already practises more Carens than its politicians admit. The first brick of a firewall is already laid in health care: since Royal Decree-law 7/2018, foreigners without registration or authorisation as residents have the right to health protection and care in the same conditions as Spanish nationals, publicly funded when nobody else is liable to pay. The social membership idea sits inside the immigration regulation of Royal Decree 1155/2024, in force since 20 May 2025, which cut the stay required for most forms of arraigo to two years and lets every holder of an arraigo permit work. The same regulation creates an individual residence and work permit for seasonal activities and writes into the regulation the workers' rights that used to sit in an annual order on collective hiring, which is Carens's equal-conditions rule for temporary workers.

The radical-centre reading takes the left's point from Carens, that years lived and worked here earn membership whatever passport you were born with, and that rights must be safe to use. It takes the liberal point that Carens himself concedes, that a democracy decides its admissions and asks for reciprocity, contributions in exchange for protection. And it adds the piece that belongs to neither camp: a clock. Spain should publish one schedule in which each right switches on at a fixed number of years of residence, from working conditions on day one to long-term status and then nationality, decided within a deadline and with no need for periodic amnesties. The firewall should extend from clinics to schools, labour inspectors and the police, so that a worker who reports an exploitative employer is protected. And the open-borders half of the book can stay where Carens put it, as a horizon, while the Cortes argue in public about how many people come in each year and through which doors.

## FAQ

### What is The Ethics of Immigration by Joseph Carens about?

It asks what democratic principles of freedom and equality imply for immigration. The first part covers citizenship, naturalisation, permanent residents, temporary workers and irregular migrants; the second covers admissions, refugees, family reunification and the case for open borders.

### What is the social membership argument?

Carens holds that a person's moral claim to belong rests on being embedded in a dense network of relationships in a society. Because that network grows with time, people who have lived somewhere for years have a claim to stay and, eventually, to citizenship, whatever their original legal status.

### What is Carens's firewall?

It is a rule that information gathered when an irregular migrant uses basic services, such as health care or schooling, or goes to the police or a labour court, cannot be passed to immigration enforcement. Without it, rights on paper go unused because people fear deportation.

### Does Carens really defend open borders?

Yes, in the second part of the book. He argues that the reasons that make free movement within a country a basic right also apply between countries, and that restricting movement by citizenship makes opportunities depend on birth. The first part of the book, though, works within the conventional view that states control admissions.

## Sources

- [The Ethics of Immigration (publisher's page)](https://global.oup.com/academic/product/the-ethics-of-immigration-9780190246792), Oxford University Press (2013)
- [The Ethics of Immigration (review by Arash Abizadeh)](https://ndpr.nd.edu/reviews/the-ethics-of-immigration/), Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews (2014)
- [The Ethics of Immigration by Joseph Carens (review by Michael Blake)](https://www.ethicsandinternationalaffairs.org/journal/the-ethics-of-immigration-by-joseph-carens), Ethics & International Affairs (2015)
- [Real Decreto-ley 7/2018, sobre el acceso universal al Sistema Nacional de Salud](https://www.boe.es/buscar/act.php?id=BOE-A-2018-10752), Boletín Oficial del Estado (2018)
- [Real Decreto 1155/2024, Reglamento de la Ley Orgánica 4/2000 sobre derechos y libertades de los extranjeros](https://www.boe.es/buscar/act.php?id=BOE-A-2024-24099), Boletín Oficial del Estado (2024)
